Romeo y Julieta 1875 Cedro Deluxe No. 2

This cigar is by far the best cigar I have ever smoked, next to the cuban version I smoked in Germany.

The R & J "1875" series Cedro is a great smoke. Dollar for dollar, one of the best you can buy. Consistent from stick to stick, mild flavor, smooth draw, cool, even burn, pleasant aroma.

Mild cigar. Creamy after taste. Good anytime of the day smoke.

Outstanding cigar!!!! I can't get enough of them.

Very nice smallish cigar, I found mine to have a nice smooth draw and an even burn. It was leathery with a full finish. Not a bad cigar to have around when you need a short little smoke.

This cigar is a very good buy for a casual or a new cigar enthusiast. It has a lot of cedar flavor and since this is true it is very one dimentional in this regard. Great to start with because flavors are very easy to pick out.

This was a different tasting cigar than your average stick. Maybe "cedar" is the best way to describe the flavor. I really didn't care for it that much. Maybe it was a little green with onlly about a month in the humidor. The burn and draw were very good and the price was right. I was just expecting more from a R&J.

Loaded with cedar flavor. It was a little more than I would have liked. Not a bad cigar overall but not was I was looking for.

Wickedbrew took the words right out of my mouth! Great looking cigar, excellent burn. Sweet, spicy cedar was consistent throughout the stick. Medium strength, medium finish. Not my preferred flavor profile, but a good smoke.

It burnt well, it was nothing spectacular but it was nice. Would smoke again....

It was a nice smoke, nothing super special, but not bad.

It's not called cedro deluxe for nothing. Cedar is definitely the predominant flavor, with some spice and an occasional nutty sweetness. I found it an enjoyable smoke. Pretty well made. Nice wrapper. Nice color. Started out burning a little uneven, but straighted out. Medium strength. Clean finish. Would smoke again at the right price.

Great Dominican for medium bodied cigar enthusiast. Smooth, slightly sweet and a bit of pepper. Good value and seems to be best size to enhance the flavor of the wrapper.

I had a few of these in my humidor, and lit one up recently as I wanted something different than my norm. It was definitely different, in the fact that the cedar flavor was a bit overpowering. It tasted like spanish cedar with a hint of spice, and a just barely discernable sweetness to it through most of the cigar. The burn was fine all the way down to the nub, and the last third had a strong tarry finish with a decent amount of black pepper. For this ring gauge it didn't get too hot. The construction and presentation was great. Overall it was not bad, just not great for my tastes either. I would recommend a purchase of these, especially if you enjoy a more woody flavor.

Ran a little, otherwise nice smoke

Solid construction, burns well, and good cigar taste. Nothing to knock your socks off, but a nice way to start your day.

As a former smoker, err maybe, I never got into cigar smoking until recently. A couple of buddies and I split a box and I will say I was hooked. The appearance is great out of the box, the construction sound, the burn great, and a mild flavor to not run me away. Haven't smoked many, but I'm sure this will alwasy be a favorite.

Had some major burn issues that distracted me troughout. This thing ran more than David Carr. I got in a sampler so mabey that was the prob.

The flavor profile in my cigar was a bit more complex than some other ratings have let on. A heavier cigar than I expected with a wonderful cedar aroma before and after lit. Good natural tobacco taste without the saccarine sweetness of milder cigars. A little expensive for me (since I'm a poor college student) but definately one of the better smokes I have enjoyed thus far.

I got myself a box off CI for $69, and let me tell you. On my next cigar purchase I will pick up another box or two of this cigar. It is great. Anytime I want to smoke something and I don't feel like being disappointed, I can count on the Cedro Deluxe. I'm always happy with this cigar.

This is my everyday cigar. I like it because it burns well, doesn't take a lot of maintenance... plus the construction is always superb (I clip the cap, so perhaps if you're poking it could be a problem)... the draw is smooth and clear, plenty of smoke. The construction is, to my opinion, fantastic as with all Romeos I've smoked. The start is confused and a bit dry, but mid-start you get some of that cedar, and then even a hint of Cohiba-like toastiness... and the rest is leather and a touch of citrus. Pretty good for under $3 (if you buy by the box)

This cigar has your classic RandJ taste. Earthy, and a cedary taste which I can only assume is from the cedar packaging. Not terribly bold, but still have a good taste.

Nice fancy presentation with the cedar and all that. Lit up well and burned straight. Lots of smoke. Ash was acceptable. Cap was an absolute train wreck. I twisted my punch into it and the whole cap spun around on the end. I licked it all up and gave it some time to heal. I could smoke it, but what a mess. The flavor was pleasant, but nothing extraordinary. About all I could come up with was tobacco and cedar chest. I had the fine wife beside me puffing on a CAO Kamasutra, and a beer, and the sunshine, and the whole day ahead. Bonus experience points for all that.

This cigar had a good, smooth construction which contributed to a nice straight burn with lots of smoke. I was impressed with how cool the smoke was which is not always true with cigars of this ring. Towards the nub this thing went out a few times after which I didn’t relight it. That may have been an ambient humidity issue though so I’m not holding that against it. The flavor on the other hand was pretty one dimensional, although not bad. I don’t remember much of what the taste was because it wasn’t very interesting. Nevertheless, it is a solid smoke with no major problems and I’d recommend it to a beginner who’s getting started on the fuller bodied smokes.

A very fine every day smoke. Medium flavor with no bad attributes. Nice balance of wood, leather, and spice. Beautifu appearance.

had to let it go out right when i started it - could be why i wasn't impressed. Started out tough draw and very spicy. Too ashy (could had been my fault), mellowed a bit in the middle then got too hot. TBN wrappers look good but dont do anything for taste and i felt like this was missing something.

Attractive, densely packed, well constrcted cigar. Body was mild. Flavor was one demensional and mundane. This had been in my box for at least a year if not longer. There just wasn't much flavor wise to interest me. Might be a solid choice for those just starting this hobby.

It's pretty good actually. I just smoked one with almost no age on it. It was a little biting, but the cedar taste really came through. I'll be interested to see how the other four I bought age. Great burn and construction, even if the stick was a little soft. I'd recommend for an everyday smoke. Nothing to get overly excited about, but enough quality that you'll be looking forward to your next one.

This cigar has been in my humi for about 6 months, I only smoked it to make some room.
I was very suprised and satisfied. The taste was wonderfully delicious. Construction was near perfect. The burn was even with long silver grey ash. Although it was on the potent side strength wise, I smoked it to the nub.

I found this cigar very woody and toasty with hints of coffee. It was mellow and subtle, but it was still stronger than it tastes or seems like. I've had much better cigars than this one for the price, however,

I read some good reviews last year and thought I tried it. Not impressed. Unfortunately most non ISOM cigars just don't have the smoothness and tangy favors and pleasant aftertaste of an ISOM.

A beautifully packaged and presented cigar, nicely crafted and pleasant to smoke. Flavors were generally mild, with notes of cedar, coffee and, not to get too absurd, but burnt pie crust. Not a particularly sweet smoke, in fact it got a little bitter toward the end. Overall, an o.k. experience

For a mild to medium smoke, this was really nice. Excellent burn and construction with not a hint of harshness or bitterness. The dominant flavor was a very nice creaminess, with cedary and toasty notes to start. Probably my favorite in the mild to medium category.

I found this RyJ to be a great smoke. Even burn with a nice mild/medium flavor with minimal aftertaste. Rich creamy smoke with enough spice not to overpower the smoke. I would recommend.

A very good cigar. Excellent taste and a nice even burn. Would definitely have this cigar again.

Doesn't live up to the normal Romeo standards, may give it a second try, tough draw with an uneven burn

An excellent mild cigar which has a very tight wrap and nice even burn. The finish has hints of green tea and spice. Smoked for about 45 minutes. One of the best I had yet.

This cigar was just plane awful, the first, second and third time I tried it. Just cause its a Romeo doesn't mean its gotta be good. This one is definitely not. It does look pretty cool though.

Had this one in the humi for 3-4 months. Bad burn with slightly difficult draw. Mild in strength. Will get a 2nd chance to improve.

I love this cigar! Haven't tried many others, but this will be hard to beat. Very pleasant spice, even, cool burn. Awesome!

Pleasant - consistent and cool all the way down to the end. Among the best I've smoked thus far.

Great cigar. Right now has to be my fav hands down

very good spice and an excellent burn. mild and smooth. overall an exceptional smoke for the price.

This is a pleasent smoke,smooth tasting nice draw good price for the quality,never had a bad RyJ..

Really enjoyed this cigar. Nice burn, great draw. Nice, strong flavor of cedar, with a sweet aftertaste. LOved the way it finished.

Very mild. Outstanding cigar. Never got hot, and it turned out to be one of those you smoked to the VERY end. 1 down - 9 to go.
10/$22 - CigarBid

Probably one of the better smokes for the buck. Good consistent flavor of coffee with hints of spice. Good mostly even burn and firm ash, but needed to be re-lit a couple of times.

strong flavor, but very harsh taste. better gars out there for the money. not like the cubans.

Bought single from local smoke shop. I didn't re-humidor the #2 🙁 and it needed it. Although the #2 was not in it's optimal state, it was an excelent smoke. A surprise...

Smooth, traditional flavor. Lots of smoke. stays cool. I LUV this one!