Have a look at the old Club Stogie Forums.  The rest of the site is under construction with little clue where or if it turns into anything worthwhile to a Lowland Gorilla.

Top25Cigar

Top25Cigar was one of the first cigar review websites.  Today it is waiting for a new life.

Club Stogie

CS was an early cigar forum that went the way of the Dodo in 2008.  A snapshot can be seen at the link below.