Graycliff Vintage 99 PG Robusto

The first three of these I had were very smooth with a deep woody/leathery finish. Great draw and great construction. I paid a very reasonable price for this outstanding smoke. I wish I would have bought more! This cigar goes well with a good scotch.

I enjoyed this smoke very much. It's a little mild for me, but is flavorful enough to enjoy. It's a rather complex smoke with wood and coffee a touch of leather and some other flavors in there too. No construction problems at all. I wish I had more of these.

This was a solid mid to mid full strengh cigar. Started off strong with a little tang but mellowed out somewhat. I would never pay full price for these, I can name at least half a dozen cigars that are superior at less that half the cost of a Graycliff. This wasn't a bad cigar but it certainly wasn't top shelf at ANY price.

This cigar starts out strong with a med+ bodied mix of oak, toast, coffee and toffee, but they all tend to drop off a bit in the first 2 inches. Though the flavor is still there the strength dies off, but it adds a nice leathery overtone until harshness sets in around 1.5 inches. Really nice if bought for a good price.

I have smoked three of these that I got from a sample pack. All three had ample complexity, with good flavor. The draw was good and the burn was somewhat uneven, but with a slight touchup it was fine. I am a fan. But I don't know that I would pay the expnsive prices they sometimes command.

I've smoked 2 of these the first was perfect, awesome flavor that changed in complexity throughout, some cedar, spice, just an awesome smoke. Wonderful draw. The second one tasted as good as the first, but the draw was very tight. I have 3 more in the humidor, got them in a sample pack. After I smoke them I'll update the review. For now I rate construction a 5, value is still an 8 because of what I paid and I'll leave the overall experience at a 7. If the other 3 have no draw issues, this is easily an 8+ cigar.