Cigar Specifications

Brand / Line:
Partagas (Cuba)
Cigar Name:
Serie D No. 4
Shape:
Robusto
Country of Origin:
Cuba
Size:
50 x 4.875
Wrapper:
Cuba
Filler:
Cuba
Binder:
Cuba
Status:
Active

0 Recent Reviews

None yet

No recent reviews yet — be the first!

159 Archival Reviews

Show ↓
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
8.50
Left me dizzy for 2 hours! Has become a semi-regular smoke as I have 2 boxes.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
8.67
Nice coffee and chocolate flavor good burn and a nice spicy finish.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$7.50
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
7.50
15 mos. in the humidor. Rustic wrapper. Easy light. Nice draw. Mostly even burn. Grey ash. Mild bodied and taste. Smooth. Not a special occasion Cuban cigar, but ok for everyday.
Appearance:6/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:7/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$5.00
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
8.80
full bodied aroma,very rich taste with woody and spicy notes,less sharp almost creamy different from the last time I smoked these!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
7.80
This is not a cigar for everybody. Due to the big gauge the aroma and flavour is enormous. Especially at the end the flavour gets very direct and massive.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:7/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$14.00
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
9.80
A fantastic smoke. Powerfull with great flavors.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
9.70
Nothing better!
Shame you can't get them in USA.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
9.80
This was a powerful, yet smooth and rich tasting Cuban Robusto. The wrapper was very dark...almost a maduro, small veined and toothy. The draw was excellent even though the construction was "rock hard". There were large volumes of soft blue/white smoke th
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$25.00
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
8.30
Nice!! A mouthful of flavor
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:7/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
8.83
A consistently great robusto. Powerful and great tasting.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
9.80
a great cigar - start to finish
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
8.00
One of the best Robustos.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:7/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$14.00
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
6.80
Obviously an excellent cigar; however, the flavor just was not there. I mean it was good, but I expected more. Maybe I should have been more patient. The ash was still a bit dark, and the draw was a bit tight. I have two more in the humidor. I will wait a
Appearance:8/10
Construction:7/10
Flavor:6/10
Value:6/10
Overall:7/10
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
9.80
THE BEST
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
8.00
Tight draw all the way. Beautifully balanced, medium body, great flavour & taste. Notable hints of dark chocolate & pepper. Aged 3 months, almost ready-to-smoke Cuban.
Appearance:6/10
Construction:7/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$13.00
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
9.30
Magnificient cigar
The best robusto
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$14.00
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
8.50
A great cigar. I only wish I could afford more.
Appearance:7/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
7.20
Flavors of roasted nuts with hints of coffee in this medium bodied smoke. Average draw and burn with a pleasing aroma. Spicy and leathery finish.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:7/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:6/10
Overall:7/10
Price Paid:$13.00
📜 Archival Review
March 1, 2026
9.30
GREAT cigar. A magic smoke experience
Appearance:10/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
January 5, 2009
9.33
"a wonderful find"
I tried this cigar due to the reviews seen on this website and found it to be as good if not better than described. The construction is the only less than 9 in my opinion. had trouble due to me usual deep drawing. then I left the band on and just slid it down the cigar to help keep it round and smokeable. Leather, spice and everything nice. bought a box and will horde them to share with my special friend Jeff E, who is the only bloke whom i know that enjoys a fine cigar as I do. we enjoy smoking cubans, and fuentes and opusx almost exclusively, but are branching out to find other wonderful tastes. highly recommend you try one. but buy two or more, because you will want another, guaranteed.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
January 3, 2009
9.99
"1997 series D No.4"
Had one from 1997 production, Wow, Wow, Wow!!! What aging can do to a cigar! Excellent smoke.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
October 28, 2008
9.17
"Out of this world"
Straight forward, woody, leathery mild, not overly complex but gorgeous aroma, perfect draw and burn, could not put it down until I burned my fingers. Consistent throughtout. Get a few if you can
Appearance:10/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
September 30, 2008
9.67
"Partigas Serie D #4"
Had this sitting in the humidor for the last 3 years. Just smoked it last weekend. Strength had lessoned some (I'd call it medium bodied), but the flavor was unbelievable. Wish I had about a dozen more with same age.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
September 17, 2008
9.99
"Abre los ojos..."
This cigar in my mind is the definitive Cuban smoke out at the moment. If you have been smoking for a while like I have, every new smoke is a welcomed experience. I had 3 of these in my humidor, and I decided to light one up with my best friend Matt over some rum and beers last weekend. Matt had a Monty Edmundo (another great new Cuban). As for the Series D No. 4, Cuban twang, sweet graham crackers, and spice are what I remember. I like this cigar because for it has the strength of a Cohiba Magico and the finesse of a Montecristo No. 2 together the two work hand in hand. The robusto size lasted about 45-50 mins, and I nubbed it. This is the type of cigar that all others should be measured by. Whether you are smoking a Cuban or not, cheap or expensive, if you have tried this beauty, afterwards, the way you look at flavor, power, smoothness, and quality all changes. When I have the opportunity to buy these again, its going to be a box. Normally, a cigar of this price would scare me, but truthfully, never smoking this again scares me a hell of a lot more.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$15.00
📜 Archival Review
August 3, 2008
9.17
"Great"
This was a great cigar - much better than the one I tried a couple years ago. It was medium-bodied and the flavor was classic Cuban. It was quite a bit stronger than I expected as well. About half way through, I was wishing I had eaten a bigger dinner before firing this one up! All in all, an excellent smoke.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
May 30, 2008
8.67
"A Nice & Unique Flavor Profile..."
I liked this smoke. The first impression was of pronounced well seasoned wood followed by a small bit of salty caramel and as it got about half way I thought it got a little spice at the end too. Still the dry aged woody taste was the main component. There are certainly more complex mixtures, you know where the flavors are either all present in equal measures or where they even jostle in order and strength, but I found this one really good and pretty unique in the bargain. No sour musky taste here...A good clean finish was noted.

Construction was very good as it drew well, burned evenly, and my ash was in excess of 2 inches before it dropped. I punched this particular one so I could really judge how easy the draw would be and, like I've already said, it was an easy draw with ample smoke.

If you want a Cuban cigar that really is unique in a very nice way I heartily recommend this.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:7/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$11.00
📜 Archival Review
May 14, 2008
8.17
"2007 was a dream year for these"
Cedary and peppary mix of flavors. Very creamy and smooth throughout. August 2007 was a great month for production. I have smoked a box from this month and am tucking 2 away for use by my future self! Guys, quit comparing these to the EL from the past...the production cigars are no where near any of the EL. Worth every penny of 9 bucks! I belive these will soon be a 9 out of 10 (10 being the padron 1926 no.9 and no.1)
Appearance:8/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$9.00
📜 Archival Review
May 9, 2008
9.50
"Mild- but otherwise outstanding"
Its a mild cigar (jul-07)- but otherwise superior. Intoxicating aroma and an awesome woody finish. Burned down to the nub perfectly.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:10/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
May 8, 2008
9.83
"Cigar Bliss"
From a 15 pack dated September '06. This might be my all-time favorite. Nearly perfect colorado wrapper with just one little "pimple" about halfway down, packed tight, pre-light scent that hinted of orange peel. Right when I lit it I got the caramel, wood and nutmeg that characterize these. No waiting around for 1/4 of the cigar to burn before the taste hits me. Rich flavors of wood, caramel and spice are so smooth and balanced. Toward the end you get a little roasted coffee thrown in as a bonus.
Refined and elegant, this is one of the best cigars on the planet.
Just a note: occasionally I read of someone complaining this is too mild or bland, and I have to think that our palates have been "dumbed down" by all of the so-called powerhouse smokes that have been popular for awhile. Maybe you got a bad one or perhaps you don't care for this type of flavor, but this cigar is the real deal. These are top-notch cigars. Try one when you have a clean palate. OK, enough preaching from me.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$7.20
📜 Archival Review
May 8, 2008
9.17
"wicked"
Tried 1 in Barbados and promptly bought a box afterwards. Small and deceptive in size, there is no denying the raw power of this Cuban. Incredibly tasty. My friends have mentioned this cigar many times before, it's a shame I've been missing out up til now. Classic Cuban taste, great price.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:10/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
April 20, 2008
8.83
"Not a big fan"
Although it has a classic cuban bite, I miss the creaminess of some cubans I have found. Perfect construction, draw and aroma.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$11.00
📜 Archival Review
April 12, 2008
9.33
"my personal favorite"
For me personally, this is consistenly the best cigar that I have ever smoked. I enjoy it much more than the Cohiba robusto and anything else for that matter. Wish they were cheaper, but oh well.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:8/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$15.00
📜 Archival Review
April 4, 2008
8.50
"I loved it"
I've had a few of these guys and I love them. The wrapper is by far one the best I've seen and it just feels so oily to the touch. The taste isn't amazing or super complex but it has such a nice flavor of spice, olive oil, and cream. This is one of my favorite smokes when it comes to smoking in the sun by the water. I recommend it with a nice vsop cognac (nothing higher, it's not worth that much). My uncle once said few people judge a cigar on the way it makes you feel after you have let it die and I think this is a quality often forgot.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:7/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
March 12, 2008
6.00
"They're alright"
Perhaps I just don't love Partagas. I must admit that I've never hated them, but they've never struck me as fine cigars. This was no exception. The color was a nice dark brown and the aroma is very pleasant. However, thae taste was simple and bland. It had a spicy, oak sort of taste but nothing really memorable. Perhaps due to the really sub-par craftsmanship (the wrapper came undone about half way down) this cigar burned very hot and tasted a little harsh in it's peak. I will continue to venture and find the Partagas that I've been longing for.
Appearance:7/10
Construction:4/10
Flavor:7/10
Value:6/10
Overall:6/10
Price Paid:$24.00
📜 Archival Review
January 23, 2008
9.50
"Grand Robusto"
I have to say this is my favorite robusto I've had... possibly ever! Great construction, perfect draw, rich creamy nutty smoke and flavor that was full but just lingered short of any harshness. I smoked it to the nub and then almost regretted it since I only have 6 left.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
January 22, 2008
9.33
"Partigas Serie D #4"
Hadn't smoked one of these in a while, and had forgotten how tasty they are. Excellent aroma, taste, and burn. One of the best for a quick smoke.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
January 14, 2008
9.00
"Compared to the 1845 No contest!"
I have always enjoyed DR 1845, but after getting one of these handed to me I was hooked. I love the Magnums and RJ Churchill, but this baby was up there in flavor and construction. A smooth cool perfect burn combined with a depth of dark spicy, yet creamy flavor. It was great to smoke while I worked at the tobacco shop and I smoked it till my fingers burned. A MUST SMOKE
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:10/10
Overall:9/10
📜 Archival Review
November 2, 2007
8.00
"Just didn't impress me"
Very well constructed. Great burn with a light medium ash. Started out rather mild but progressed into a stonger taste. Definitely spicy and peppery but I didn't think the flavor was that complex or remarkable considering especially the reputation it has.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:7/10
Value:6/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
September 8, 2007
8.00
"Wood Spice bombardment"
This is a fantastic spicy cigar. When it’s on it’s ON. Smoked some that were in their dead period which was very bland so leave them along for 6 to 9 month before trying again. You be greatly rewarded once they exit the dead period.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:8/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$7.60
📜 Archival Review
August 28, 2007
9.17
"Craftsmanship"
Top notch construction on this cigar. An oily chestnut colored wrapper surrounds an ample amount of aromatic tobacco. Absolutely perfect draw produces plumes of smoke with flavors ranging from cream to almonds and cedar. Medium bodied with some spice. A year in the humidor has improved an already delicious cigar. Highly recommended and very reasonably priced.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
July 25, 2007
8.33
"fantastic"
This is a great smoke. Excellent flavour, good spice and earthy notes and a touch of something sweet in there. Love the robusto size to keep the palette cool. Wish it could have lasted longer.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:8/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$25.00
📜 Archival Review
July 19, 2007
9.50
"One of the best"
In my opinion one of the best cigars to come out of Cuba. Unique flavor and aroma, complex and satisfying.Very good construction, great draw.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
July 18, 2007
8.17
"Grade: B+"
The flavor on this cigar is just delicious and is exactly what I think of when I day dream about smoking a cigar. It somewhat peppery, leathery, very woody in a way a could only describe as the harmony of a Cuban. The first 2 thirds of the cigar I consider to be very smooth and crisp but the last third is anything but. A wall of spice hits you that is nothing short of a grand finale. For me this is more of the kind of smoke I consider perfect to light up on a breezy afternoon relaxing (texas heat so consider the source). That said I will personally stick with the Bolivar Belicoso Fino's. I prefer more of a punch in face in a cigar as I am more of an evening smoker (stronger flavor). I will still keep a few on hand for the aforementioned breezy afternoon (rarity) though and when I do smoke one, I will cherish every minute of it.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:6/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$9.00
📜 Archival Review
June 5, 2007
8.00
"One of my favorites"
A great, stout cigar with a nice dark wrapper. Somewhat peppery and leathery with a medium to full body. Very cuban. Very tasty.
This one usually ends up being one of my "go-to's". A great size for mid-day or evenings. Never aged any, but I suspect they would age well.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:7/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$11.00
📜 Archival Review
May 14, 2007
8.33
"Strong cigar"
Started out a bit toasty then got leathery and spicy. very strong cigar. I agree that any who got a mild one , may have had a fake. Very good all the way down. Very spicy in the last third. Had a slight canoe at the start but it self corrected. All in all it is a very good smoke. But I also agree that it may not be for a beginner.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:7/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$15.00
📜 Archival Review
January 10, 2007
9.33
"A very good cigar"
An excellent Robusto. Definitely one of top 3 robustos on the planet. Starts off smooth and then about 1/2 inch in, look out. Loots of leather and wood and about half way down, here comes the nicotine. If you don't smoke regularly, be careful as the power and nicotine of this cigar will sneak up and knock you up side of the head. You really should smoke this one after a good meal.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$7.35
📜 Archival Review
January 1, 2007
9.99
"INCREDIBLE!!!"
Perfect. That is it! Perfect!!!
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$20.00
📜 Archival Review
December 12, 2006
9.17
"A staple in the CC stable"
Sorry, but anybody using the words "pale" or "mild" in their reviews of this cc has to question their source. Non-counterfeit PSD4s are anything but. This is a solid cc, with earthy, flavorful Cuban taste. One of my "go-to" ccs.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:10/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$9.00
📜 Archival Review
December 11, 2006
5.17
"I'm with Darbarian on this one"
A spongy, pale stick with a mottled wrapper. Started mild, with a persistent grassy character and a short finish. Burn and draw were fine, but the flavor improved only modestly over time. It picked up a little spice and leather at the end, but too little, too late. I've had some superb D4s in the past, but this box from early '05 has been a disappointment. A friend got a similarly unimpressive box dated at roughly the same time. It seems that last year was something of a down year for this sometimes stunning smoke. In the future, I'll think twice before picking this one over a RASS, Famoso or Bolivar RC.
Appearance:6/10
Construction:7/10
Flavor:4/10
Value:4/10
Overall:5/10
Price Paid:$9.75
📜 Archival Review
December 7, 2006
4.17
"sO-sO"
This is not a 10 dollar cigar, it is not even a five dollar cigar. It may be one of the first Cuban Cigars that I have sampled to be just adequate yard gar. It tasted of old soil, and not in a good cuban way. Perhaps the roller had dirty hands? The burn was a little off and the aroma was barnyard. Just not a great smoke for the price at all.
Appearance:7/10
Construction:6/10
Flavor:3/10
Value:3/10
Overall:3/10
Price Paid:$11.00
📜 Archival Review
November 15, 2006
5.33
"Lower Shelf"
Well, I admit that I had no opportunity to age this cigar since I was traveling when I purchased it. I found it to be bitter strong like an old cup of coffee. i could not finish it, which gave me a bad impression given the price. Nothing special here, especially for a cuban.
Appearance:7/10
Construction:7/10
Flavor:3/10
Value:3/10
Overall:6/10
Price Paid:$11.00
📜 Archival Review
October 28, 2006
8.50
"Top robusto"
Just what you expect from Partagas. A well built, good looking stick with full earthy and spice flavours. The big gauge works well, allowing a slower smoother and cooler smoke which takes away the raw harshness you get from thin Partagas sticks and allows the flavours to develop to a creamy leather as it warms. I don’t think it’s quite a Specially Selected or an Epicture2, but for what it is, its one of the best.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$20.00
📜 Archival Review
October 14, 2006
8.67
"Great cigar!!"
I always get a feeling in my stomach when liting up a cuban cigar. Sort of like lighting history. I know. Sort of silly.

This is a very good cigar. I just love the muskyness of the flavor and smell of cubans and this does not dissapoint.

Someone coming from Canada bought these for me for about 25$. A little pricy but I took them anyway.

Nice spiciness. Good smoke and great lingering smoke and flavor.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:7/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$25.00
📜 Archival Review
October 14, 2006
9.17
"Not for everyone, but very good"
Some people don't like them, but for me they are just right. This is one of my favourites. Extremely good in every respect. In my opinion far better then the Cohiba robusto. Here is my tip: Age them! They are a very good smoke already, but it is with age that they really shine.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:10/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$16.00
📜 Archival Review
October 6, 2006
7.67
"Perfectly good gar"
Nothing to write home about. However if you want the taste of Patagas this is a good plece to start. All the flavour of the others in th range without the dry earthyness. Being a robusto this is a more rounded, medium flavour of earth and rich tobacco. Personally i fin the PC and the Super Partagas more interesting bu this very much has its place for those with a pallet for the mediub body/ full flavour smoke
Appearance:8/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:6/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$20.00
📜 Archival Review
October 4, 2006
8.50
"Great Smoke"
Construction was impeccable. Flavor was medium too full, but not as strong as the Dominican Blacks. Taste was complex and better towards the end with a medium finish.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:7/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$20.00
📜 Archival Review
September 6, 2006
9.67
"Fantastic"
My boss and I got to talking about cigars the other day... he revealed that he had a large stash of authentic cubans. He brought me in one of these and... DAMN it was tasty. Flavorful, medium bodied and perfectly spicy. This cigar lives up to the cuban hype.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
📜 Archival Review
August 20, 2006
8.67
"Still lovem!"
Just finished another box of early 05's and was quite satisfied with them and sat down a box of late 05's for a few year rest. Several out of the last box were kick ass spicey and the rest were very tasty. Have talked and herfed with several BOTL's that have varying opinions on the D4's. Lots of bland comments but the few boxes that I've smoked, have been very lucky to have a good experience. Other than being a bit spongy on a few they still tickle my fancy. My favorite robusto. Maybe a lovem or hatem vitola?
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$7.00
📜 Archival Review
August 19, 2006
7.50
"Just not a huge fan."
I've smoked a lot of these and they just don't do too much for me. I don't think they're bad, but they just don't give me the Partagas flavor I expect. When on, I get pleasant spices, when off, I get nothing at all.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:7/10
Value:7/10
Overall:7/10
Price Paid:$7.00
📜 Archival Review
August 14, 2006
9.00
"Series D #4"
Excellent habana. Complex taste. Became very creamy in last 1/2 with hint of coffee. Started with a nutty flavor. Extremely nice clean burn.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
August 7, 2006
8.83
"Great"
Got this cigar for free at a conference. Rich flavor with plumes of smoke. This was an awesome cigar in every aspect. Off the charts appearance and flavor. Very spicy towards the end. As a pretty regular cigar smoker, I was surprised by the buzz I got of this one.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:7/10
Overall:9/10
📜 Archival Review
July 25, 2006
8.50
"Without a doubt"
This is the finest box after box cigar in the world! This is my 6th box spanning 4 rolling years(03-06) and no other cigar comes close to consistent taste and smoking quality. A very flavorful, medium bodied cigar with perfect burn and draw. My only regret is I can't seem to age them. They're just too good out of the box.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$7.50
📜 Archival Review
July 23, 2006
9.50
"a pleasure"
Everything you'd expect in a great cigar! These have such a spellbinding aroma and the flavors are just bold and beautiful. So darn good!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$9.00
📜 Archival Review
June 20, 2006
9.83
"Findly"
Well I findly got my hands on a box of these Habanos. This is my first cuban and I'm totally impressed, what more can I say! I cant not describe how much I enjoyed this beauty. The construction was perfect and the flavors are bold and creamy. If I was a rich man this would be my everyday smoke. I truly think this is the Best!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$9.60
📜 Archival Review
June 14, 2006
9.00
"A year later and..."
Here I am a little over a year later, when I decided to smoke the second of my gifted No. 4's. The additional age improved the good flavor and made this stick a spice bomb. I enjoyed the first cigar (reviewed 6/6/05) and this one was even better. The biggest difference between the two sticks, was the construction. The first was a little tight, while this one was perfect. The draw was excellent, affording loads of tastey smoke. Overall these are very enjoyable cigars and I look forward to more of these in the future.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:10/10
Overall:9/10
📜 Archival Review
June 3, 2006
8.33
"Dic 05"
A very serious cigar with a sophisticated flavor. Classic cuban roll, with the flat head and triple cap, firm to the touch. Burns slowly and a little unevenly at first. Some green flavors to start out, then becomes toasty with a bold corojo-like aroma. The spice picks up at the 3/4 mark and sets my tongue a-tingling. Toward the end the smoke is intoxicating, lots of pepper, and what a buzz... construction on this stick could have been better, but the taste and outstanding aroma make up for it in every way. I can't wait to see what a year or two in the humidor does for these.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:7/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
April 29, 2006
9.00
"TASTY..STRONG..BUILT LIKE A BRICK POWERHOUSE"
They just don't roll them anywhere else like they roll them in Cuba. A handsome chestnut brown wrapper, the roll was packed tight with tobacco, like a rock. If this were a Dominican, Honduran, or Nicaraguan, I would have been reaching for the draw poker. The burn and draw were perfect, as I would expect from a Cuban Partagas cigar. I usually am lucky to get 20-25 minutes out of a cigar this size, I got almost an hour of a delicious and memorable treat. Bursting with flavor, even with the light puffs I was taking, so the extra full bodied smoke would not overpower me. A complex mix of fruits, nuts, breads, spices, maybe hints of coffee and cocoa. If you ever have a chance to try a Cuban cigar, I highly recommend this Partagas Serie D#4.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$9.00
📜 Archival Review
March 18, 2006
9.33
"Da Best"
I have had the pleasure of smoking a lot of these cigars. I have to say they are the best. I prefer these over monte #2 and any other cubans I have tried. Complex and smooth. I keep these in my humi for all to enjoy. Top of my list.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:8/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$7.25
📜 Archival Review
March 14, 2006
9.50
"Wonderful"
Had this cigar about a week ago on vacation. What a great smoke. Build was good, a couple veins, but nothing to complain about. Burned extremely well with an even ash all the way down. Taste was good. Creamy, with some nutty flavors. Seriously enjoyable cigar, will not hesitate to say this is the best cigar I have ever had.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$15.00
📜 Archival Review
February 5, 2006
9.50
"great stick"
Just had a serie D no. 4 yesterday. One of the best cigars I have had in a long time. Can't complain.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
January 21, 2006
9.33
"a nice cigar for a relatively warm day"
what I mild day and I thought what a nice way to walk the dogs around noon with nothing but a nice robusto. The D4 got the call. I was concern about the "sick" issue because this stick is only ~4-6 months old. Gladly, this wasn't.

The prelight draw was easy and cedar-ed flavored. Toasting the foot was no issue and after the first few puffs, the cigar unleashed a coffee like flavor almost like a nice espresso. The finish was a hint of spice and cedar. Half way through, the flavor change a tad to me tasting some cocoa with coffee still the prevailing flavor. the finish remain the same, the draw was smooth, the burn was even, the dogs did their business; lo and behold I was back at home--the cigar at this time was nothing but a nub and a good memory.


This is my second D4 and I remain very impress with the taste and consistency.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
January 16, 2006
9.50
"Best smoked Robusto ever!"
I had my doubt about smoking this cigar since it is not my favorite "shape" to smoke, but soon enough I was a true beliver in this outstanding piece of work. I greatly enjoyed smiking it. The flavors, the smoke and the hull where just plain perfect!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
📜 Archival Review
January 14, 2006
8.83
"First smoke"
Smoked a Seris D. No. 4 for the first time tonight. Well consructed with a nice velvet smooth wrapper. It was a bit moist and as a result a little tight on the draw. After about 1/2" this cigar came awake. Full flavored and spicy without any harshness. As it I smoked this robusto, it became more powerful with a great finish. Near the end I had a slight feeling as if I had been punched in the stomach. Alas the end came and I had to put it down. For as young as this smoke was (box code July 05) it tasted good. I can't wait to see what a couple of months/years will do to this wonderful cigar. I have smoked very few Cubans, but I imagine this cigar is the essense of a Cuban cigar.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$7.80
📜 Archival Review
January 11, 2006
9.17
"powerful smoke"
very strong smoke, not for the beginner. Burnt well and stayed consistent all the way through.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$9.75
📜 Archival Review
January 6, 2006
9.83
"Let me join the herd"
I had my very first D4 tonite. handsome looking robusto with nice feel o it. pre-light boquet was woodsy. lighted up without an issue and by the second puff, i tasted a spicy finish. after 1/2 an inch, it unravel a creamy slighytly sweet taste medium body taste with the spicy finish taking a backseat nonetheless, it still make your tongue aware. this continued on puff afther puff of nice thick white smoke, with a nice balckish ash build-up. the last inch and half was taken over by the spiciness which i did not mind but the smoke got hot and i had to say goodbye. the things i read prior to this smoke was not hype, it was all and then some! Good thing I have three more sticks--i figure one per 2006 quarter 🙂
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
January 2, 2006
9.99
"One of the BEST!!!"
I just got a box of these and they are hands down, my favorite Robusto. Great flavor/construction/aroma.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$8.50
📜 Archival Review
January 1, 2006
9.67
"You're still the one"
This is one of the first Cuban cigars I ever smoked, and it remains one of my favorites. I recently broke open a box I have been storing for about two years, and the result is nothing short of astonishing. Fresh off the truck, the D4 is a peppery, spicy and complex masterpiece. But with some age under its belt, it rivals any cigar, of any age, and any price, that I have ever had. This is what Cubans are all about.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
December 4, 2005
9.67
"If Emilio Rebenga's last smoke..."
...before Tony Montana gutted him was a Series D #4, he died a happy man. I bought some Cuban Monty #2s, Series D #4s and Siglo 2s in Saint Marten while on vacation. I had a chance to enjoy one of these beauties on a secluded beach while sipping Carib (the local Corona type beer of the Virgin Islands) and watching the thong clad hotties frolic in the crystal blue waters. Wow. Amazing full flavor...yet not overwhelming or too spicy. Smooth. Tons of smoke. Great construction. Nutty, complex flavor profile. Pricey...but worth every penny. I expect to pay $10 for a good stick...and this is certainly world class.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
December 4, 2005
9.67
"Now we're talkin' good smokes!"
This is one of the finest robustos (in every way) one could ever hope to smoke-and that's out of the box...add 5-7 years in proper storing conditions and you have yourself a real special occasion treat that will absolutely take you by suprise...nothing compares. (I might add that a Bolivar Busto with 5 years is hard to beat as well, but that's a totally different taste profile)-I'm tired of hearing "this cigar is way better than that one" and such, when they're completely different..."I like these flavors more than those" would sound much more intelligent!-If you like milk chocolate, tanned leather and spice, THIS ONE'S FOR YOU!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
November 29, 2005
9.33
"Best Robusto"
This is the best non EL robusto from cuba. Prelit to finish this robusto is much better than the Cohiba robusto and for less money.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
November 28, 2005
9.67
"Cheers!"
Exquisite. Smoked this beauty in a great Cuban bar in Cadiz. The wrapper was very dark and when lit exploded with flavor. The flavors built as it was smoked and never had a dull moment. It remained cool right down to the nub. Aroma, finish, burn, all were amazing. One of the best cigars in the world. Highly recommend!
Appearance:10/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$9.00
📜 Archival Review
November 25, 2005
9.50
"the absolute best"
hands down this beauty is the best cigar I have smoked - it is full of flavor, burns like a cigar should, & I give it a 9.5
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$15.00
📜 Archival Review
November 9, 2005
9.83
"The Best Robusto!"
This is by far the best and most consistenr robusto IMHO. The taste is more complex than the Cohiba Robusto and you don't have to age it to get the full experience. Very consistant in build, draw and burn, but its taste is as good as it gets for the robusto vitola.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$9.34
📜 Archival Review
October 16, 2005
8.67
"A serious cigar"
This is the cigar that the DR Partagas seem to be attempting to emulate...badly. It is nutty, oaky with a strong sweet tobacco flavor. Never tarry, and with only a very slight burn irregularity (probably because I was smoking it so slow to enjoy it more). Lots of Vitamin N, and a clean burn to the nub. This is probably my favorite cigar in the full-bodied category. It's not a cheap cigar, but definitely a good one.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.92
📜 Archival Review
August 23, 2005
8.67
"great smoke"
Dark Cocoa, occasional black cherry, nice milk chocolate wrapper, smokes like a dream when aged for greater than 6 months
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
August 13, 2005
9.00
"The Holy Grail!!!"
Smoked this cigar on a cruise recently and was blown away at the quality. The full bodied cigar is remarkebly smooth and flavorfull. It is constructed very well and has a lovely light brown wrapper. The cigar lights, burns, and draws well to the simple fire engine red band. The only bad thind about this cigar is the embargo. Can't we all get along???
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$18.00
📜 Archival Review
July 30, 2005
8.83
"good"
great cigar, lots of woody flavor. i have found though that the woody taste is not my flavor profile.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
July 26, 2005
8.83
"DAMN!"
This is a spicy flavor bomb! The draw was a little tight and this was a mild to medium stogie that I smoked right to my burning fingers. Cubans are really something SPECIAL and I am just starting to sample them!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:5/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$14.00
📜 Archival Review
July 22, 2005
9.17
"A Serious Robusto"
Damm! This was a awesome cigar. I don't have a refined palate as most of these reviewers but I must admit the (2) PSD#4s that I smoked were both flavor bombs. I can't really describe it, maybe a nutty-wood burning taste? Body was on a heavier side of medium to full. When I think of a traditional "Cuban" or "ISOM" this vitola comes to mind. I paid dearly for them considering Cubans are not legal where I'm from so this is definitely a special occasion cigar. Highly recommended among ISOMs.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:7/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$15.00
📜 Archival Review
July 13, 2005
6.17
"so so..."
If I had not heard so much hype about this cigar before I tried it, I would have been much happier with it. Because of all the talk, I was somewhat disappointed. The aroma was very nice, but the flavor was nothing that I can't find in a dozen other non-Cubans. It was definitely a pleasant smoke, but nothing special. Flavors included licorice and nuts with some burnt marshmallow over a general tobacco flavor. The construction of this stick is where it was most lacking. The draw was tight the whole way through and the burn was a bit uneven. Also, it died on me about 3/4 of the way through and had to be re-lit. A friend of mine had one with me and his did not have any of those problems, so I guess I just got a dud. All in all, not a bad experience, but I was expecting much more.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:4/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:3/10
Overall:7/10
Price Paid:$15.00
📜 Archival Review
June 26, 2005
9.00
"One fine smoke"
this is one fine smoke there boys! Just finished one and it does live up the all the hype. It had very good but not great construction and burn. It was quite a crooked burn for half the smoke then corrected itself to perfect. The aroma was excellent and the flavors of spice, wood, nutmeg and some cinnamon. The smoke is extreamly creamy and smooth slowly building in power to the end. This is one fine smoke!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$7.50
📜 Archival Review
June 23, 2005
9.50
"Burned my fingers too"
I picked up one of these in the Caymans several weeks ago. This is a great cigar. I'd trade 2 Siglio II's for one of these any day. I've nubbed a lot of great smokes, but honestly there was only about 3/8's of an inch left when I finally gave up. The burn was pretty even and the draw was not tight at all, actually a little loose. I wouldn't rate this cigar as strong, just very flavorful. I'll definately be looking for a few more of these on my next trip.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
June 11, 2005
8.17
"Burnt finger tip"
I literally burned my finger on this cigar. The flavor was a combination of wood and spice. The finish is very nice, even better than the original taste of the smoke. The best way to describe it is very spicy. The construction is good, but the draw on this one was a little tight. The burn was even until the very end and when I say end, I mean the very end. I was gifted two of these by a CBID member, so I have another in the humidor. I plan to let it age a few months before trying it again.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:7/10
Value:10/10
Overall:8/10
📜 Archival Review
May 30, 2005
8.83
"Excellent cigar"
Had this ENE05 sitting in my humi for about 3 months at 65%. Great looking cigar, with an easy draw and lots of delicious smoke. Those wonderful Partagas flavors in a nice sized cigar. This one had some burn problems and wanted to run a bit, but the flavor and loads of smoke more than made up for the corrections required. A definite top of the line keeper!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
May 27, 2005
9.83
"Outstanding Freshie - PSD4"
I wanted to get in a quickie review after a "lunch break" while the taste was still fresh and yummy in my mouth...

Just finished the first out of a box of Dec '04 PSD4's, and it is without doubt the best fresh Partagas cigar I have ever had. Period. Just exploding with those Party flavors we all love, and absolutely the most delicious sweet and spicy finish I have yet experienced in a young D4. Feel like I just finished a great meal, including the dessert. Construction, draw and burn: just plain perfect.

This is a cigar to enjoy now, but be sure to put some away because this will be truly awesome later. Don't miss this one...

Love dem freshies!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$7.00
📜 Archival Review
May 20, 2005
9.83
"Addicted"
I've grown addicted to this cigar. This is my cigar of choice. Easy even draw, wonderful aroma, even burn and a cigar that you want to savor as long as possible. In the past year I've been fortunate to be able to try many of the Cubans and by far these are the best in terms of price, quality, and personal taste. Only other cigar that I smoke more of is the Bolivar coronas, and only because it is much cheaper.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$17.00
📜 Archival Review
May 10, 2005
6.83
"I respectfully disagree..."
This is the second serie D4 I've tried of about seven Cubans (Hoyo de Monterrey, Romeo & Julietta, and Bolivar too..). Don't get me wrong... the Cubans are very good... BUT, they just generally are so good as to justify the price. I think the Hoyo de Monterrey Dark Sumatra, La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero, Hansotia Ancient Warrior, CAO Brazilia (especially Anacondas), Puros Indos Maduros and Victorias, etc. etc. more than measure up...especially when you consider value. While I will most certainly be interested in Cubans in the future.... I will not pay a premium for them every again.....
Appearance:8/10
Construction:7/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:5/10
Overall:6/10
Price Paid:$15.00
📜 Archival Review
April 24, 2005
9.00
"Smokin'"
A small smooth delightfull cigar. Plenty of taste, easy draw, suptlities. For a serious gar smoker, may be too much for unexperienced.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$20.00
📜 Archival Review
April 21, 2005
9.99
"Best ever"
I dont know alot of the talk about how cigars taste like ceder or nuts or cinnamon.But I do no what I like.I have been smoking cigars for over 30 years and this is the best cigar I have ever smoked period.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
March 23, 2005
9.50
"Wonderful!!!!!"
I have heard the hype. I have read others' reviews with jealousy. Now I have my own to try, and try I did. This harmless appearing robusto has a tawny brown wrapper with medium veins. Solid construction with no soft spots and a fantastic prelight aroma. Easy light. PERFECT draw (best I've had). TONS of billowy white smoke reminiscent of the last PAM64 Imperial I had, from a smoke volume standpoint. From a flavor standpoint, this started off with some spice and mild cedar. It developed into a rich, complex, creamy taste with notes of wood, leather, and roasted nuts. I smoked it before dinner, which was a mistake. Don't take its short stature for an underpowered cigar - this one can pack a punch! The one hour experience left me with burnt fingers, but it was worth it. The hype is real.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
📜 Archival Review
March 16, 2005
8.67
"Yum Yum"
Only drawback on this cigar was the "draw" itself. hehehehe Excellent construction, good burn, medium bodied smoke with hints of vanilla and nutmeg. Consistent tobacco flavors throughout......Great Aroma!
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:7/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$11.00
📜 Archival Review
February 28, 2005
9.67
"Classic Cuban In All Aspects"
I have held out on my post of this Classic Cuban Vitola for the better part of a year.
My box of these gems has been resting for over 2 years in one of my D'ors. What can I say, that has not already been said? All aspects of this Vitola are A1. Great taste, Flavors and top notch construction. I read other posts that said it was mild? Never! smooth yes but with a full bodied kick. It's a must try, but remember if they are genuine sit down and enjoy after a full meal. It will blow your mind.
No hype!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$15.00
📜 Archival Review
February 26, 2005
9.83
"WOW!"
My first box of Partagas D4s...now I can see what all the hoopla is about, and I can't believe it took me this long to try this top-notch robustos. Out-performs the Cohiba robusto by a good bit, and I, until now was quite partial to the Bolivar Royal Corona as my favorite robusto. This takes the cake, fellow aficionados. The draw delivers mouthfuls of smoke so rich you can almost chew it it. The bean tastes are there, and I swear I can taste a black cherry note as well. I can't wait till some age takes on these great smokes, and I need to buy a couple more to age. I recommend this cigar in the highest possible way.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$8.80
📜 Archival Review
February 20, 2005
8.67
"Smooooth"
Smooth is this sticks middle name,great robusto. The hype is true about this gem. Excellent flavor,tons of smoke. My favorite to date. Get some,you'll be glad you did..
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$7.50
📜 Archival Review
February 5, 2005
8.50
"A Great Robusto"
After a Cohiba, this is my favorite Cuban robusto. After smoking a few boxes worth, I have yet to have a bad experience with one. Flavorful is how I would describe this cigar without being overpowering. Cigar Aficianado has this stick rated somewhat lower than other robustos lately. Don't believe it, get a box!
Appearance:8/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$10.50
📜 Archival Review
February 3, 2005
8.33
"Gotta watch for the"
These are great smokes, but you gotta be careful of hitting the sick period. Needs a good 6 if not 9 or 12 months in the humidor to be at optimum smoothness and flavor.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
January 21, 2005
8.83
"Great Smoke"
Bought a box after I was gifted one by a fellow smoker. This cigar will not dissapoint. Believe everything you have heard, this is a classic full bodied Cuban.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$9.00
📜 Archival Review
January 3, 2005
9.00
"Benchmark"
Full bodied, rich and ages well, the #4 is a benchmark for earhy, cocoa and straight tobacco flavors. Experienced smokers can enjoy this after lunch as well as a rich meal. A real pleasure.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$7.50
📜 Archival Review
December 21, 2004
8.33
"Potent"
Not for your beginner. Has a nice punch with a little spice. Great after dinner smoke.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:8/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$15.00
📜 Archival Review
November 3, 2004
9.83
"A classic"
Wow, what can I say that hasn't been said? This is a flavor powerhouse, gobs of smoke, perfect draw, burn slightly uneven and flaky ash, hence the 9, but everything else is just fabulous. Despite the massive flavors, this cigar is smooth all the way down. Excuse me while I go buy some more..... A rip snorting cigar.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$7.00
📜 Archival Review
October 19, 2004
8.83
"Alas, Last one"
Last of the box. Seamless, smooth and oily with a perfect cap. Excellent draw. Mountains of smoke. Spice, leather, some cocoa. There is strenghth in this cigar. Now to find another box...
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
October 18, 2004
9.00
"Shame they finish..."
Smoke #3 of a particularly intense smoking week end (a Vegas Robaina Unicos and a wonderful Italian cigar, an Antico Toscano, were also on the list), the D4 was the icing on the cake. Quite powerful but smooth, very well blended flavours (say cocoa and leather, mainly, an almost impeccable construction and a very even burning ring (even in the wind) were its assets. I can't recall any liability, but the sad moment I had to see it go, not before it started burning my fingers....Not for the faint at heart, though, given its inner strength. Value is no issue with a cigar like this!
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
September 22, 2004
8.50
"Great Robusto"
I smoked several of these while recently away and must say it was a great cigar. Draw was hard on some of these and on others perfect. Flavor was intense in either case and I really enjoyed. A great value also when you can find, as with all good cuban cigars the better they are the harder to find.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:7/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
September 7, 2004
8.33
"Complete"
My favorite Robusto! Balanced, good draw, plenty of flavour, good burn. A well made cigar all around and a value compared to the Cohiba. Have had a couple with poor draw, burn and flavour, but they were kept in "questionable" conditions to be fair.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:10/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$7.00
📜 Archival Review
August 23, 2004
7.17
"Variable"
Some of these are so spicy and leathery that they make you swoon, others are flat and metallic. No rhyme or reason either. But when they are on they are epic, so I always take the risk.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:7/10
Overall:6/10
Price Paid:$9.00
📜 Archival Review
August 23, 2004
9.83
"Very nice"
What a wounderful cigar.There is just something about a partagas I just love there flavor!!
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
August 22, 2004
8.83
"Nice"
Medium body smoke that did not disappoint. Started off tasting a little like an OpusX and then shuffled through earth, wood and spice flavors. Draw was perfect and the burn was surprisingly good.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
August 16, 2004
9.00
"Yeah, baby!"
When I go to Oporto, Portugal (actually Vila Nova de Gaia) to review the
available ports and decide which vintages are appropriate to lay down, I
usually eschew the Lisboa to Oporto connection on TAP in favor of a
leisurely drive across Spain. A flight to Madrid, and then an afternoon
drive through the Moorish section of Spain seems to melt the tension and
leave me more refreshed and ready to relax at the port houses. It also
allows for the procurement of reasonably priced cigars for the drive.

These were from a lonely box of SD #4s I found in the middle of Madrid. I
picked them up and then headed for the bull ring for an evening's
relaxation. The crowd was lively, the weather beautiful, and these cigars
smoked very well out of the box. The date code said they were almost a year
old when I bought them, but they smoked smooth and with characteristic
power.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$7.00
📜 Archival Review
July 27, 2004
9.00
"Testing the hype."
Smoked this cigar for the first time right from the box. Big fan of Cohiba Robusto and MC #2 and this did not disappoint. Left me dizzy but the aroma and flavor was wonderful.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:10/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
July 11, 2004
8.33
"10.00"
Great cigar. All the hype was true! Medium-Strong bodied, smooth draw. Earthy, spicy, woody tastes through the smoke.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:9/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
July 9, 2004
9.17
"EVERYTHING I want from a cigar!"
Bought a box in Spain in october 2003. Now, they are so incredible full and smooth! People with bad experiences of this cigar probably smoked it too soon or too moist.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:8/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$8.68
📜 Archival Review
June 19, 2004
9.83
"One of my favorite Cubans.....AWESOME"
This really is a great cigar and I'm suprised that its review average isn't higher, say in the low 9's. Regardless, the construction is just as flawless as the draw with a slow and even burn that demonstrates the artisian grace this baby was made with. Full bodied with deep notes of spice, wood, and a few other complexities that I can't describe. Everything is in perfect balance keeping the Partagas power in balance with the smoothness cigar-lovers have come to expect from top of the line smokes. Definitely worth $10 and more. Bravo!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$7.50
📜 Archival Review
June 13, 2004
9.83
"One of my favorite Cubans.....AWESOME"
This really is a great cigar and I'm suprised that its review average isn't higher, say in the low 9's. Regardless, the construction is just as flawless as the draw with a slow and even burn that demonstrates the artisian grace this baby was made with. Full bodied with deep notes of spice, wood, and a few other complexities that I can't describe. Everything is in perfect balance keeping the Partagas power in balance with the smoothness cigar-lovers have come to expect from top of the line smokes. Definitely worth $10 and more. Bravo!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
June 7, 2004
9.99
"Great Cigar"
This is a great cigar with an excellent burn and draw. It starts off mildly spicy and becomes rich and intence midway through. It is among the best cigars in its class.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$7.25
📜 Archival Review
April 28, 2004
7.17
"Delicious, spicy"
Outstanding, spicy, quick smoke. Good and strong, but not overpowering. The nose is wicked good, the aroma is very pungent and strong.
Appearance:7/10
Construction:7/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:7/10
Overall:7/10
Price Paid:$11.00
📜 Archival Review
April 27, 2004
9.33
"You better be ready."
This cigar has great flavor and a nice oily wrapper. I bought a box and I have had good luck with the 5 I have had so far. This is NOT a beginner smoke as it knocked 2 of my buddies square on their butts 🙂
Appearance:10/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:10/10
Overall:9/10
📜 Archival Review
April 26, 2004
8.67
"Inconsistently Fabulous"
Had two of these lately. One was absolutely fabulous, while the other was plugged. Both had perfect dark chocolate color with oily wrapper. Strong but smooth. Not for beginners. Complex flavor of nuts and chocolate. A must try.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:7/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$14.00
📜 Archival Review
April 13, 2004
9.33
"Great Smoke!!!"
Had a couple on my vacation in Varadero, Cuba. Definitely very full-bodied, complex, and flavourful. Plus - the smoke was only $4.40 a stick at a government store, $110 a box!!!! Highly recommended
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$4.40
📜 Archival Review
March 4, 2004
8.50
"Great through the middle"
Beginning to half way through phenomenal, but got harsh the last couple of inches. Very full bodied.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:7/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$19.00
📜 Archival Review
February 14, 2004
9.33
"holy shhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh"
This was a wonderful, spicy little thing. Clouds of smoke!!! Spicey with pepper, and some woody notes. The best cuban Ive had in a long time.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$20.00
📜 Archival Review
December 28, 2003
9.33
"great"
great cigar. perfect construction. flavor started out spicy, then moved to nutty and finished with a strong chocolate flavor. very interesting cigar.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$5.00
📜 Archival Review
December 23, 2003
9.00
"Box Code - FRH SEP 03"
The draw was a bit firm, but it lit easily and burned smoothly through the first half. The wrapper was silky smooth and had no large veins. The flavor was text book for a PSD4. Through the first half it was woody with a good amount of hot pepper spice. Initially there were hints of black cherries. The second half of the cigar was not as complex, an overwhelming spicy flavor dominated the cigar and the strength grew with every draw. Eventually the cigar began burning under the wrapper and it culmnated with a sharp bitter finish.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
December 12, 2003
9.67
"best i've ever had"
i dont' know what the guys below me were smokin, but it must not have been a real PSD4. very complex, peppery/spicey, a little chocolate in the last half. perfect burn, draw was so easy and smooth (like breathing), not harsh in the least bit. box date was april 03. i'm buying a box, my first entire box for myself. there's no way a CAO Criollo could come close in flavor (i've had many of those as well). i chose 10 for value, i'd pay upwards of $20 a cigar for these, but i only payed half.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
September 3, 2003
9.99
"my favorite cuban"
I love this cigar, looks and smells great, smoking it is a joy, it is full of flavor, draws easily, and always lasts me a good hour. I only wish it wasn't so expensive ($16), or I'd smoke them everyday
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:10/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$16.00
📜 Archival Review
September 3, 2003
9.50
"fantastic"
fantastic robusto, had my head spinning. Not very complex but full bodied and very powerful. Bought a box and have smoked 2, can't wait to smoke the rest
Appearance:10/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:8/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$16.00
📜 Archival Review
August 6, 2003
4.17
"Give it up Castro!"
Yet another over hyped Cuban. If and when Cubans become legal they will be like when Coors moved east of the Rockies and people realized the rest of the beer industry had left it in the dust. This cigar is bitter, harsh and leathery. In fact it taste so much like the CAO Criollo Conquistador they could have come from the same manufacturer except the Part is not as refined as the CAO. The really sad thing is I still have two of these rancid sticks festering in my humidor.
Appearance:6/10
Construction:6/10
Flavor:4/10
Value:1/10
Overall:4/10
Price Paid:$20.00
📜 Archival Review
July 14, 2003
8.33
"Excellent"
This smoke with a pint of Guiness is about as good as it gets. I usually smoke larger cigars, but this robusto burns slowly enough that you don't feel rushed. The cigar is complex and tasty, never harsh. It is a bit expensive, though, as seems to be the case with all Cuban cigars. Overall, a nice treat. If these were priced comparably to Nicaraguan cigars, I'd smoke these all the time.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:6/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
June 13, 2003
2.33
"What a Disappointment"
I am sorry I purchased a box of these cigars. I have smoked a lot of cuban partagas and the Series 4 was just awful!! Taste, draw, and burn were terrible. I had to keep lighting this cigar to keep it burning. At first I thought it was just the cigar but the whole box is like this. A serious disappointment from Partagas. I think there all carrying this Limited Edition thing too far.
Appearance:5/10
Construction:5/10
Flavor:1/10
Value:1/10
Overall:1/10
Price Paid:$14.25
📜 Archival Review
June 4, 2003
7.33
"Good, but"
Nice powerful smoke with a decent amount of power. My only gripe with this smoke was the cap. After I clipped the cigar, the remainder of the cap came off and the wrapper had some problems after that.

The flavor was was a strong woody flavor with a good amount of spicyness. I liked it a lot, but not as much as the Serie D #3. I also didn't think that it lived up to the hype around this smoke.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:7/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:7/10
Overall:7/10
Price Paid:$20.00
📜 Archival Review
May 18, 2003
7.67
"No.4"
Colors in the box were mixed, but I have heard this before. That aside, what an interesting Cuban smoke. The flavor changes like colors in a sunset. I need to try again after some time in the humidor, but I really enjoyed this cigar.
Appearance:6/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:7/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$20.00
📜 Archival Review
February 26, 2003
7.17
"Worthy of hype"
I've got a box of these to work through the first one Dec of 99. Was a hearty smoke with good construction and a good unique flavour. Can't wait to work my to the bottom of the box.
Appearance:6/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:7/10
Overall:7/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
February 25, 2003
8.67
"Great Robusto"
Construction was excellent, but off the start I have had three boxes of these beauties and they have been inconsistent in color, some dark maduro color other more of a greenish olive like color. HOWEVER they all smoked beaufiully. Very oily and smooth, a medium plus to full bodied complex cigar. Had chocolate and spice with a wonderful aftertaste. You can not go wrong with this cigar, one of my favorite cubans









Excellent construction. Wonderful supple feeling in mouth and hand. A perfect effortless draw. Just loads of thick rich smoke. Med/full bodied. Richly flavored and deeply complex. Deep rich loam, coffee beans, and a strong chocolate appearance made this cigar almost indescribable. Creamy texture. Long finish that was fabulouse. The aroma was spicy and perfumed. Just heavenly. I’ve got
more aging that I can barely wait to try.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$15.00
📜 Archival Review
February 17, 2003
9.67
"All out flavor"
Though this cigar doesn't make for the best of presentations, compared to other Partagas vitolas, however, any experience with this cigar will allow you to quickly dismiss its less than regal appearance, because its flavor is one of the world's finest. It is oh so rich upon the palate with heavy robust full-bodied notes of soil and cedar, yet creamy like a dark chocolate mousse. This cigar is simply divine to smoke. Highly sought after, sometimes impossible to buy, the Paratagas Serie D No. 4 is a must for your humidor.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
January 29, 2003
8.67
"when they're good . . ."
when they're good, they're great! My only concern is inconsistency. I've had some that were a little pale and bland, and another batch that were dark, oily, and fantastic.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$9.00
📜 Archival Review
January 16, 2003
8.17
"Strong foundation gar"
Excellent draw, strong foundation in flavor and spice, great aroma
Appearance:7/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:7/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$14.00
📜 Archival Review
January 14, 2003
9.33
"ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE!"
THIS PD4 HAS TO BE ONE OF MY FAVOURITE ROBUSTOS AROUND BY FAR. TRUE QUALITY AND A HEARTY CIGAR WITH A HONEY NOTES. THIS PD4 IF NOT A CLASSIC IT WILL BE SOON...AN EXCELLENT AFTER DINNER CIGAR!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$14.00
📜 Archival Review
January 12, 2003
9.50
"Amazing robusto"
Need i say more about this little powerhouse of a cigar. From start to finish this full bodied rich tatsing robusto is amazing, it makes me wanting more. A big bang for the buck and a must for the cigar lover's humidor!
Appearance:10/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:8/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$18.00
📜 Archival Review
December 31, 2002
9.33
"A GREAT ROBOSTO"
Second only to the Cohiba Robosto, this powerhouse is a true landmark cigar in the Partagas line. Great cuban aroma, tastes of nuts, creamy and eathly undertones. A must have in humidor.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:8/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
November 25, 2002
8.83
"One of the best"
This cigar is definitely one of the best around. It is smooth, well rounded-if not one dimensional, and mild. But is it worth its $15.00 price tag? Not really considering that the Padron 1964 is just as good. So are some of the CAO cigars. Still this cigar is one of the best.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$15.00
📜 Archival Review
November 15, 2002
8.83
"BAM!"
I love this cigar - and they are only going to get better with age. Complex and powerful. Draw is great but burn is somewhat erratic, I expect this to improve with age. This is one Cuban that did not disappoint!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
September 14, 2002
9.33
"An excellent robusto"
An excellent robusto. Lots of smoke, consistent construction and flavor. Ages with the best of them. A must for aficianados.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:7/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$10.00
📜 Archival Review
September 10, 2002
8.83
"POW!"
Simply one of the best cigars out there period. Looks great, burns well, simply a great cigar. Med-full bodied that was smooth and plenty of flavor. I wish I bought more.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$12.00
📜 Archival Review
August 18, 2002
7.50
"D-licious"
Top of the line construction. A bit homely. Powerful complex smoke with notes of black cherry and earthy spice. Nice draw. I have noticed quite a bit of flavor inconsistency however, from one stick to another.
Appearance:6/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:7/10
Overall:8/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
August 18, 2002
8.83
"What a cuban"
This cigar is what smoking is about. Everything about this smoke was great Partagas should be proud about this one.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
July 19, 2002
9.67
"Stick to my guns"
I rated this cigar about a month ago. Have not smoked it for a while, since had some other new Cuban arrivals, after coming back from Spain and England. Just had one after lunch with a cup of espresso and boy o boy, it is a true Partagas from good old days.
I would like to stick to every single word I said in my previous rating. They are just fabulous robustos.
Though I am more of a Churchill and Double Corona man, this beautiful robusto just knocked my socks off.
Could not agree more with the latest rating of 94 in Cigar Aficionado
Appearance:10/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
June 12, 2002
9.33
"One of the best robustos"
Came from a box of October 2000 and Sep. 2001.
A dark and oily robusto that draws like a dream...earthy and woody, with leather and molasses notes with long somewhat spicy finish. It's medium to full bodied, with excellent ageing potential..
Compared to the production years prior to 2000 just keeps getting better.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
May 8, 2002
9.33
"A staple in My humi..."
A great draw that almost smokes itself..this robusto delivers spectacular flavors..I've had these with the wrappers a redish color and had them very dark..both excellent..notes of cocoa ..and rich smoke..always on My short list of must haves.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$8.22
📜 Archival Review
April 20, 2002
9.50
"In my "top 5"."
In my "top 5". Nothing special to look at. Little nutty/cedary/creamy. That great cuban aroma! Smoking through a box. No construction problems(so far).
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$7.40
📜 Archival Review
April 15, 2002
9.00
....and then I went to heaven...
Appearance:10/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00

Add Your Review

Share your experience with this cigar. All reviews are moderated before appearing on the site.

Appearance:
Construction:
Flavor:
Value:
Overall Experience: