Cigar Specifications

Brand / Line:
Romeo y Julieta 1875
Cigar Name:
125th Anniversary
Shape:
Churchill
Country of Origin:
Dominican Republic
Size:
50 x 7.625
Wrapper:
Ecuador
Filler:
Dominican Republic
Binder:
Mexico
Status:
Active

0 Recent Reviews

None yet

No recent reviews yet — be the first!

14 Archival Reviews

Show ↓
📜 Archival Review
March 9, 2026
6.33
"Best one they make"
I have been a critic of Dominican RyJ ever since Tabacalera bought them. This may be the best sicgar they make
Appearance:7/10
Construction:6/10
Flavor:7/10
Value:6/10
Overall:6/10
Price Paid:$7.00
📜 Archival Review
March 9, 2026
8.80
You know what they say about opinions...everyone's got one. Anyway I got the beautiful black humidor as a Christmas gift. I tend to like mild to medium cigars, but gave this medium to strong Churchill a '9'. A great smoke!
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
March 9, 2026
9.20
A beautiful cigar. Starts medium and builds to full. Smokes cool, even, with a clean, gray ash. Better than Opus! If you don't have any yet, find them!
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:9/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
March 9, 2026
9.50
THE BEST NON-CUBAN CIGAR I EVER SMOKED. EXCELLENT TASTE,PERFECT DRAW, GREAT ASH AND PLEASANT AROMA. ALSO, I BOUGHT IT FROM GLOBAL NETWORK(OUT OF NEW YORK). 24 CIGARS CAME IN A SPECTACULAR HAND PAINTED HUMIDOR FOR $149.00 THAT CAME OUT TO $6.00 A CIGAR WI
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
April 9, 2008
5.17
"average smoke"
nothing to get really excited about. Nice wrapper and burned really well. flavor was average at best.
Appearance:6/10
Construction:6/10
Flavor:5/10
Value:4/10
Overall:5/10
Price Paid:$6.00
📜 Archival Review
January 7, 2006
6.00
"average cigar"
nothing spectacular for a 125th anniversary. taste not much different than an original D.R. RyJ, construction was so so and mine fell apart while smoking
Appearance:6/10
Construction:6/10
Flavor:6/10
Value:6/10
Overall:6/10
Price Paid:$5.00
📜 Archival Review
January 13, 2005
5.67
"Worthless"
even after two years of age this cigar looks great, burns great and is absolutely tasteless. Would gladly trade for some great $4.00 858's
Appearance:9/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:4/10
Value:2/10
Overall:5/10
Price Paid:$8.00
📜 Archival Review
September 17, 2004
7.33
"What's all the bragging about?"
Paid about $150 for a box of 25 @ JR's. The box / humidor is now my everyday humidor and worth $100 easily. The cigars are worth the other $50, but no more. Decent flavor, draw, and burn, but not ANYWHERE worth $6+ each. Buy one occasionally for a treat, or buy a box to get the humidor, but this is no show stopper.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:8/10
Value:5/10
Overall:7/10
Price Paid:$6.00
📜 Archival Review
April 13, 2004
9.00
"Just Great, No Other Explination but Great`"
This cigar delivered pleasing smoke. Nice flavors, even burn, nice. Only word to describe it... GREAT! You must smoke these, weather you're a fan or not.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:8/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$7.50
📜 Archival Review
November 20, 2003
3.00
"crap"
must have gotten a bad one ,uneven burn, tight draw, one of the worst cigars ive smoked
Appearance:6/10
Construction:2/10
Flavor:5/10
Value:1/10
Overall:2/10
Price Paid:$8.80
📜 Archival Review
November 17, 2003
9.17
"Great"
What a great smoke! Not as much bite as a regular 1875, but much smoother with the trademark slightly sweet finish I've come to love about RyJ's. Perfect light, draw and burn, will get a box.
Appearance:8/10
Construction:9/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:8/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$8.50
📜 Archival Review
March 13, 2003
3.50
"Above Average Cigar"
Not a bad cigar. The cigar burned very well, nice ash. It seemed to lack a distinct flavor. It was a little woodsy, a little nutty. Overall an average to a little above average smoke.
Appearance:4/10
Construction:4/10
Flavor:3/10
Value:4/10
Overall:3/10
Price Paid:$9.00
📜 Archival Review
December 28, 2002
9.33
"Best of the Dom Romeos"
Rich and refined flavor. Woody, but not smokey with a hint of nuts. Definatly worth another go around.
Appearance:9/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:9/10
Value:8/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$14.00
📜 Archival Review
September 15, 2002
9.83
"Great cigar"
EXTREMELY WONDERFUL cigar. Beautifully made and packaged. Perfection construction. Full of favor and excitement. As for value, I have rarely smoked $30+ cigars better than this. This cigar made me feel love again.
Appearance:10/10
Construction:10/10
Flavor:10/10
Value:9/10
Overall:10/10
Price Paid:$7.20

Add Your Review

Share your experience with this cigar. All reviews are moderated before appearing on the site.

Appearance:
Construction:
Flavor:
Value:
Overall Experience: