Romeo y Julieta Reserve Real Toro

Very creamy and smooth. The scent is sweet with alot of smoke produced. I had a slight uneven burn and smoke a bit fast for my likeing. Has a slight harshness in the aftertaste. Otherwise, well constructed.

Very nice looking stick, above average in all other facets, but nothing stands else stands out as exceptional. Just a plain good cigar.

THis cigar falls a little short for me.

There is nothing wrong with it, the flavors are all there, it is constructed well enough. It is just missing a certain X factor, which really left me feeling almost cheated, as it received a very high rating. Never the less, it is a very good cigar for the money. Not something I will be smoking on a regular basis though.

Construction was OK. Burned even but a little fast. Flavor was very smooth and mild. All in all, just not strong enough for me.

I think this is one of my favorite medium blends. I've had this and the churchill size and both are marvelous. The toro was a bit cooler but had that same sweet creaminess that I've come to love in this line. I would smoke these again and again. The look and construction are supurb and the cigar evolves ever so slowly from mild-medium to medium and never ever gets harsh or biting. It's always smooth, always buttery - A perfect lazy Sunday cigar that takes no thinking to enjoy.

A really good smoke. Not as strong as the Reserve or Anniversary. Too bad the price is so high.

For someone who searchs for a medium bodied cigar that is of high quality construction and just looks great, this cigar was a perfect fit. The flavor was not too strong but maybe a tad weak is the only complaint I have.

I got a deal on a couple at my local smoke shop, and tried em. I had read a lot about em and wanted to try them. I got em home and fired one up. Very nice aroma, taste was good but a little subtle. I could taste the spices and the nuts and cocoa but all a bit subdued. The draw was smooth and just right; a well made cigar. The value was great, a lot of cigar for what I paid (~$4.00). In general they are pricey and I wouldn't buy a box of em but, if they come in a good sampler or a 5 pack, I will buy them. They are a kind of a mood cigar IMO, and a good alternative stick in my humidor.

An attractive, very smokable cigar. However, harsh and boring in the all important flavor department. This stick just had no flavor going for it. I kept on waiting for something other than a bitterness to develop. Nothing. Just blah...even yucky. This stick's wrapper was shiny. Gauge said she was "good" to smoke. She was properly humidified for about 2 weeks in my box. Bought her for about $3.25 on an Indian Reservation that had a properly maintained walk in humidor. I noticed these sticks go for about $5/stick. Was this a fake? Maybe. But this dealer is usually reputable, and why would you want to counterfeit a $5 stick? Strange....maybe I got the bad stick in the box. If so, this is twice I've been disapointed by Romeo y Juliet.
I'd tread cautiously with these as beauty is only wrapper deep.

really good!!!!!!!!!!!

Not a better looking cigar in my experience. It's a shame to burn it. Taste reminds me of a fine dry white wine. Hints of straw along with a cream flavor. Understated but sophisticated tasting smoke. Probably too mild to smoke with great regularity but a very nice change to mid-heavy body maduros. My only complaint is that it tends to burn kind of quick. This with humidity levels at 67 to 68% in my humidor. It's a good idea to be patient with the draw. Recommended.

I wonder if I smoked the same cigar as the other reviewers. I found it to be medium bodied with lots of woodsy flavors. A little nut and spice, too. It burned perfectly and had a great draw. I didn't pay much (only $2.00 as part of a promotional 4-pack), which added to the value.

Some of these reviewers must be employed by RJ. I bought a box of these a year and a half ago. Since then, I've tried without success to find a good one. All of them are plugged, flavorless, bland, and boring. Every single cigar in my box burned badly, had a constricted draw, and produced very little smoke. These cigars are just not good.

This is a very good smoke with great aroma that reminds me of it's cuban sister. The burn is even and the flavor is wonderful. I am not a large cigar fan but I can put in the time for this one on occasion.

Bought a box, great construction and medium/mild smoke, smoked most of them till they burt my fingers...yes they're that good, all of them consistantly good, pretty good bang for the buck!

This is one cigar I have found myself coming back to quite often. Such a smooth smoke, with supurb construction...making it among my favorites. Well worth the money.

There's not much to these when it comes to flavor. Light and mild with a smooth finish. Pay for the name.

Well built cigars. Nice, mild flavor. However, I've had several that suffered from either a tight draw or very low quantity of smoke. Mild cigar that is better than average.

Smoked a box of these and not one bad stick. Perfect construction, great draw, mellow but tasteful. I enjoyed every one.

I agree with El Gato. I was hoping for a little more in the flavor department. But overall a
very good smoke.

Almost too good looking to smoke. Medium body with good flavors. Could be more complex. Burns perfectly.
Makes a nice gift, especially for a special occasion.