People are allowed to dislike the Nubs AFTER they TRIED (<---Key word) them.
Bashing the Cigar before you try it..doesn't even warrant a comment in the first place.
I respectfully disagree.
I do agree that one should not form negative opinions on the flavor of the cigar without trying one.
BUT, people are certainly "allowed" and justified in their negative impresssion of the cigar based on goofy dimensions, a less than favorable first impression of the owner and the hype surrounding the cigar.